High-Protein Low-Sugar Peanut Butter Cup Yogurt Hack Recipe

Jun 13 2023
We saw the high-protein peanut butter yogurt hack going around on TikTok and had to give it a try with our own low-sugar spin. Our sundae recipe has just four ingredients, and that DIY Magic Shell topping is so satisfying to crack before eating!

Hungry Girl's HealthyPeanut Butter Cup Yogurt Recipe

Print Peanut Butter Cup Yogurt Print

Entire recipe: 170 calories, 8g total fat (3.5g sat. fat), 140mg sodium, 16.5g carbs, 5.5g fiber, 1.5g sugars, 15.5g protein

Click for WW Points® value*

Prep: 5 minutes
Cook: 5 minutes or less
Freeze: 20 minutes


One 5.3-oz. container zero-sugar vanilla Greek yogurt (like Chobani Zero Sugar)

1 tbsp. powdered peanut butter (like PB2 Original)

1 tbsp. sugar-free chocolate chips (like the kind by ChocZero)

1 1/2 tsp. chopped peanuts


Combine yogurt with powdered peanut butter. (You can do this right in the yogurt container or a small bowl.) Mix until uniform.

Place chocolate chips in a small microwave-safe bowl. Microwave for 35 seconds, or until melted. Stir well.

Spread melted chocolate over yogurt. Top with peanuts.

Freeze until chocolate has hardened, 15–20 minutes.


See how it's done… Soooo easy and so fun! Click to watch.

Shop the Recipe on Amazon!

Order the shelf-stable ingredients for this high-protein low-sugar peanut butter cup yogurt recipe now, then pick up the vanilla Greek yogurt on your next grocery run!

Chew on this:

Happy National Kitchen Klutzes of America Day, June 13th! If this is your day, we're gonna leave this set of finger guards right here. (No judgment.)

Let your friends have some DIY Magic Shell fun too! Share the recipe for today's high-protein low-sugar peanut butter cup yogurt recipe.


We may receive affiliate compensation from some of these links. Prices and availability are subject to change.

We may have received free samples of food, which in no way influences whether these products are reviewed favorably, unfavorably, mentioned with indifference, or mentioned at all. Click for more about our editorial and advertising policies.

*The WW Points® values for these products and/or recipes were calculated by Hungry Girl and are not an endorsement or approval of the product, recipe or its manufacturer or developer by WW International, Inc., the owner of the Points® trademark.

Questions on the WW Points® values listed? Click here.

Hungry Girl provides general information about food and lifestyle. This information and any linked materials are not intended and should not be construed as medical advice, nor is the information a substitute for professional medical expertise or treatment. Click here for more information.